This early cemetery behind the church has monuments dating from 1861 to 1904. John Arthur has contributed digital images of each of them that he made on a visit to Jamberoo in October 2007. The list of inscriptions for this cemetery has been compiled from those images and with reference to the NSW BDM indices for further information.
Behind this cemetery is the Anglican cemetery and beyond that again is the Presbyterian cemetery in Allowrie Street. The Anglican headstones were originally listed here but those listings have since been moved to our Jamberoo Anglican cemetery record.